Loan Comparison Calculator

No signup. No email. Just calculate.

Your details

Loan A

$
%
yrs

Loan B

$
%
yrs

Loan A costs less

A$129

total savings over the loan

Loan A

A$495.03/mo

Total A$29,702

Interest A$4,702

Loan B

A$414.32/mo

Total A$29,831

Interest A$4,831

Total cost comparison

Loading chart…

Want this calculator on your own site?

Powered by FinCalcs · Free financial calculators

Two loan offers, two sets of numbers — which is actually cheaper? This loan comparison calculator puts two loans side by side, showing each one's monthly payment, total interest and total cost so you can compare them on equal footing. A lower monthly payment doesn't always mean a cheaper loan, and a lower rate over a longer term can cost more overall. Enter the details of both offers and let the totals reveal the better deal.

How to use the Loan Comparison Calculator

  1. 1Enter the amount, rate and term for Loan A.
  2. 2Enter the amount, rate and term for Loan B.
  3. 3Compare the monthly payment of each loan.
  4. 4Compare the total interest and total cost.
  5. 5See which loan is cheaper overall and by how much.

What is Loan Comparison?

Comparing loans properly is one of the most valuable financial skills, because the headline that lenders advertise — usually the monthly payment or the interest rate — rarely tells the whole story. Two loans can look similar on the surface yet differ by thousands of dollars in total cost once the term, rate and fees are all accounted for.

The trap most borrowers fall into is focusing on the monthly payment alone. A lower monthly payment feels more affordable, but it's often achieved by stretching the loan over a longer term — and a longer term means more payments and far more total interest, even at the same or a lower rate. The honest comparison looks at the total cost: the monthly payment multiplied by the number of payments, which reveals everything you'll actually hand over.

The interest rate, expressed as APR, is the next key factor. APR is more useful than the nominal rate because it folds in certain fees, giving a truer annual cost. When two loans have different rates and terms, comparing APRs alone still isn't enough — you need to combine rate and term into total interest paid to see which wins. A loan with a slightly higher rate but a shorter term can easily beat a lower-rate, longer-term loan on total cost.

This is exactly what a side-by-side comparison clarifies. By computing each loan's fixed monthly payment and then its total interest and total cost, you can see not just which has the lower payment, but which is genuinely cheaper over its life — and quantify the difference. Sometimes the cheaper loan has a higher monthly payment that's still well within budget, making the extra savings well worth it.

Beyond the numbers, consider features that don't show up in a simple comparison: prepayment penalties, variable versus fixed rates, origination fees, and flexibility. But the foundation of any sound decision is an apples-to-apples cost comparison, and that's what this calculator provides — letting you choose the loan that costs you the least, not just the one that looks easiest each month.

The formula

For each loan: Monthly payment = P × [r(1+r)^n] / [(1+r)^n − 1], r = rate ÷ 12, n = months
Total cost = monthly payment × n
Total interest = total cost − P

The lower total cost is the cheaper loan.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I compare two loans?+

Compare them on total cost, not just monthly payment. Calculate each loan's monthly payment, then multiply by the number of payments to get total cost and total interest. The loan with the lower total cost is genuinely cheaper, even if its monthly payment is higher.

Why isn't the lowest monthly payment the best deal?+

A low monthly payment is often achieved by extending the term, which adds more payments and more total interest. Over the life of the loan, a low payment can cost far more than a higher payment on a shorter term.

Should I compare interest rate or APR?+

Use APR when possible — it includes certain fees along with the interest rate, giving a more complete annual cost. But always combine rate and term into total interest, since APR alone doesn't capture how term length affects total cost.

What else matters besides cost when comparing loans?+

Check for prepayment penalties, whether the rate is fixed or variable, origination and other fees, and repayment flexibility. These can affect the real cost and convenience beyond the basic payment math.

This calculator is for informational and educational purposes only. Results are estimates and should not be considered financial advice. Always consult a qualified financial professional before making financial decisions.

Related Calculators